Every fall/winter season, I break out my Spanx and Commando faux leather leggings. To me, they are staples I can't live without and especially in 2020, I find myself wearing them more than denim. The most common question I get asked is the difference between the two and which pair to buy. They are in fact quite different, which is why I have both pairs and wear them each for different reasons. Last year I wrote about the faux leather leggings I never knew I needed: Commando leggings. I also have a highlight saved on my Instagram comparing the Commando leggings to the highly popular Spanx leggings and, just in case you missed it, I wanted to write about the comparison between the shapewear lines’ leggings today! You can also read about my Spanx review here! Scroll to the end for outfit ideas with both the Spanx and Commando faux leather leggings.
Click the images below for full outfit details.
Faux Leather Leggings
Spanx vs. Commando
When you lay the two next to each other, you can instantly see the difference. Commando faux leather leggings look so much more authentically leather compared to the Spanx. Spanx leggings have a more athleisure/workout legging look, whereas the Commando could pass for a fitted leather pant. Another big difference is the finish on the hem of each legging. Commando has a raw/unfinished hem, and Spanx’s is finished. Finally Spanx has a outer side seam, while Commando does not.
The Commando leggings have a grainy texture just like real leather products do, again giving them that authentic look. The Spanx leggings appear as though there was a sheen applied, giving them a shiny look. In terms of warmth, I found the Commando leggings to be much warmer when I wore them in Iceland (but I was still freezing because, ya know—it was Iceland!).
As far as the fit goes, the Spanx leggings look shorter but because of their insane amount of stretch, they actually end up wearing longer, matching the length of the Commando/slightly longer. Of course, the Spanx fit like Spanx in that they hold everything in, tightly. The Commando leggings fit snuggly, but not to the level of intensity that Spanx products do. The other major difference in terms of fit are the waistlines—Commando’s is vertical whereas Spanx is horizontal. Also, Commando have a mesh liner built into the top to conceal any lines from your underwear, which is lovely! I wear size small in both pairs.
They are both incredibly comfortable and I find myself reaching for them on a daily basis. For me, Spanx are great for long travel days or lounging around the house because of their extreme stretch. While the Commando are still super comfortable, they aren't as forgiving, so sitting cross-legged isn't as easy as in the Spanx.
I wear a size small in both the Spanx and Commando and find them to fit true to size. The Commando will look much smaller when you get them, but they will stretch as you put them on, and over time relax. Neither pair stretch out, they just relax as mentioned.
I'll be honest, I actually don't remember exactly what the care instructions are. I just wash inside out on cold/gentle cycle and lay flat to dry.
Truthfully, I don’t think you can go wrong with either legging—it all comes down to personal preference, and I definitely prefer the Commando. To me, it’s the best faux leather legging out there and reads more as leather than the Spanx. They cost the same ($98), so whichever style looks best on your figure is worth the investment either way!